Sunday, September 28, 2008

Advice?

When I am faced with a major decision I often turn to a specific person that I am close to whom I feel will understand. Some situations I survey several people I am close to for advice and take a mixture of the advice. In general I turn to who I feel will best be able to help me based on the level at which they know me.


I found reading a few sides from www.sidetaker.com really interesting. One was about him not being supportive of his wife going back to school because he wanted a larger family right then. Well that was an easy side to take. But others like the women dating the man who recreationally smokes pot, but not wanting to date a recreational pot smoker is a little tougher to pick a side. Personally I can easily pick a side, but why is dating the guy if she knew this?


For me the situation depends if I would trust the crowd or the advice columnist more. I currently volunteer for an online teen help site as a Mentor. What I do is open messages other members have sent and see if I could reply. If I have a good response I reply, however each message is replied to about 6-8 times. So the member asking for advice is getting a selected crowds advice. I personally think this is a good method because each person in the crowd was selected based on a level of commitment and questions we answered but none of us are experts.

1 comment:

Amanda said...

I completely agree, that advice from a crowd or specific person is situational. It goes along with what we discussed in class, if your friends already have their mind made up about someone then they are not the people to go to in order to get an unbiased, true opinion. As with many things in life, the best answer is often "It Depends."